
It's me again, the stuffed sweet potato girl. This time I'm bringing you these Primal Buffalo Chicken Stuffed Sweet Potatoes with a tangy Blue Cheese Dressing. If you haven't noticed from my Stuffed Sweet Potatoes and Enchilada Stuffed Sweet Potatoes, I'm kind of having a kick with stuffing this sweet, nutritious, root vegetable with all types of savory things. I'm the kind of girl who finds a shirt she likes and buys it in 5 colors. Simplicity and routine are two things I love.

I've been craving buffalo chicken lately and having it on a salad like the one below in Meals Made Simple just wasn't cutting it, so I thought I'd throw it inside the cavity of a sweet potato. I also didn't have time to do it in the slow cooker like in the book, so I did this stove top and it was a quick meal to prepare! I also have an Instant Pot version below along with a step-by-step video! I often just grab an organic plain rotisserie chicken at Whole Foods for quick dinners and using the leftover shredded meat in this as well.
You can leave out the cheese if you want to keep these primal buffalo chicken stuffed sweet potatoes paleo and Whole30. I use Humboldt Fog instead of blue cheese here because it is goat cheese and I tolerate that better, as opposed to cow's milk. A lot of blue cheese can also contain gluten, so this is a safer bet and has such as delicious flavor.

Watch my step-by-step video below:




Samantha @ WhatsUpUSANA
Looks good! Totally understand keeping simplicity and routine in life 🙂
Victoria Lerman
Made this tonight for dinner with what I already had- Rotisserie chicken and over a salad with avocado and cucumber. It was delicious!! Thank you for a perfect buffalo sauce recipe! 🙂
Danielle
You’re welcome! So glad you liked it!
Danielle
It would be difficult to say exactly how much meal you’d need because I call for whole cashews in the recipe. I would suggest with sticking with whole cashews so you get the correct measurement. Or you can experiment and let me know how it goes haha!
Daniel Patrick
How spicy is the sauce? I’m a “light weight” when it comes to spice. I don’t find most of your recipes too spicy but just had to check!
Danielle
It totally depends on theft sauce you use. I don’t think it’s too spicy but it definitely has a bit of a kick. You could start out with half the amount and see what you think.
Tammie Gilstrap Herring
If you generally don’t like mayo…what would you substitute?
Danielle
If you can tolerate greek yogurt, you could try that. You could also use a dairy-free, unsweetened, tart yogurt.
Danielle
You’re welcome! I’m so glad you liked it
Rebecca Francis
Thank you this is delicious! One of my husband’s favorites is buffalo wings with blue cheese dressing, and he enjoyed this as a substitute which is just awesome! I made a batch of dressing for myself without the cheese and it is still so flavorful. What a hit!
Danielle
Thank you Rebecca! I’m so glad you guys liked it 🙂
DiannaWorm
This was fantastic! All but my most heat-sensitive one loved it! Yum!
Danielle
Thank you!
Carrie Begley
I’m wondering if this could be done in the slower cooker too, instead of on the stove top. Has anyone tried that?
Danielle
It definitely could!
Jan W.
So you only simmer the chicken in the hot sauce, vinegar and spices? No water added?
Danielle
Correct!
Alissabeth
Do you have a dairy free ranch suggestion?
Danielle
Yep! You can find my recipe here- https://againstallgraincom.bigscoots-staging.com/2014/02/04/buffalo-wings-dairy-free-ranch-dressing/
Janice Rosmini
Delicious! It has become one of our favorite meals. We substitute regular mayo with avocado mayo.
Danielle
Yum!
Tom D. Wilson
Looks delicious. Can’t wait to try it. Wondering how the cooking time would be impacted using an already cooked rotisserie chicken? Thanks!
Danielle
You could shred the chicken and mix up the sauce with it and heat until hot!
Danielle
You’re so welcome! Glad you tried it out and enjoyed it. 🙂
Rebecca Bo
We don’t have Humboldt Fog goat cheese in our area. Do you have any other suggestions? This looks delicious!
Danielle
A standard chevre goat cheese will work just fine too!
Kayla
Montchevre makes a cheese called Bucheron that tastes very similar to Humboldt Fog and is less expensive.
Stephanie Larsen
Next time I make this, I’d simplify it. Simply bake the sweet potatoes in the microwave instead of covering them with fat and salt and baking them in the oven (or boil them until soft if they’re too fat to microwave easily). Could the filling be made with butter instead of the harder-to-find ghee or coconut oil? I cut the chicken into bite-sized chunks before cooking them instead of shredding them. That worked fine. Since we’re not fond of the empty calories of celery, I just doubled the amount of carrots. I think I’ll add some onion next time, too. Thanks, Danielle, for an interesting recipe. I like combining the savory and the hot sauce with the sweetness of the sweet potatoes.
Laura Colleen
Danielle, any specific recommendations if trying to prepare this as a freezer meal? Thank you!
Danielle
You could probably do the chicken and sauce in advance, but everything else needs to be made fresh.
Cindy Sherman Koeltl
Is there something else to substitute for the cayenne pepper hot sauce and cayenne pepper? My kids and I like mild, but my husband likes spicy! We love your Stuffed Enchilada Sweet Potato recipe:)
handcranked
Thanks so much for this recipe! This is one of my favorite dishes. I honestly didn’t expect to like it that much based on the ingredients, but it’s amazing.
We just got an Instant Pot and now I’ve made it in the Instant Pot a couple of times. I think you may have a mistake in step 2 for the Instant Pot because you mention garlic, but there only seems to be garlic in the dressing. One other thing is that I think the cooking time in the Instant Pot is a bit too long. Both times I’ve made it, the chicken has cooked to over 200 degrees. I’d knock at least 2 minutes off the cooking time unless you’re using frozen chicken. The Instant Pot site says 6 to 8 minutes for boneless chicken breasts, although I’m not sure if they’re doing a quick release or not.
Danielle
Happy to hear! Thanks for sharing 🙂
Danielle
So happy you enjoyed it!
Samantha
I know this is such an old recipe but it is simply one of favorite and the one I crave the most! I have taken leftover and mixed them with scrambled eggs for an ahhhhmazing breakfast! Yummmmm!
Danielle
it is also one of our favorites 🙂 We still make it all the time! So glad you love it too!!
Sheila
I know this was posted a while ago but just getting around to making it. The ingredients call for white vinegar but the instructions say white WINE vinegar- which should it be?